|
Calcium is removed from the tightly bound part of the
bone to maintain blood levels only when dietary intake is inadequate and
the more mobile stores are exhausted. Bone undergoes a constant
remodeling process with 20 percent of an adult’s bone calcium
re-absorbed and replaced every year.
Muscle contraction
Calcium plays a vital role in muscle contraction. It is also
necessary for heartbeat regulation through its effects on heart muscle.
Nervous system
Calcium is essential for nerve impulse conduction. It plays a role
in the release of neurotransmitters and activates some enzymes which
generate neurotransmitters.
Cardiovascular system and blood
Calcium interacts with sodium, potassium and magnesium to regulate
blood pressure and water balance. A major class of drugs used to lower
high blood pressure blocks the channels which transport calcium across
muscle cell membranes. Calcium also plays a role in the activation of
prothrombin (which is formed from vitamin K in the liver) which is
essential to the blood clotting process.
Other functions
Calcium is essential for cell division, healthy immune function, for
enzyme activity and for the production and activity of hormones involved
in digestion, energy and fat metabolism, and the production of saliva.
It is also involved in the transport of nutrients and other substances
across cell membranes.
Absorption and metabolism
On average, adults absorb around 25 to 50 percent of dietary
calcium. Some is absorbed passively while some is transported via a
vitamin D-mediated process. Most absorption occurs in the small
intestine. The calcium then passes into the exchangeable calcium pool
that is in the body fluids. This pool turns over 20 to 30 times a day
whereas the calcium in bone turns over every five to six years.
Blood levels of calcium are tightly regulated by the
hormones calcitonin, parathyroid hormone and vitamin D. These hormones
act together to regulate calcium levels as dietary intake and
requirements vary. They control absorption from the gut, excretion in
the kidney and the rate of bone formation and breakdown. In the absence
of vitamin D, less than 10 percent of dietary calcium may be absorbed.
When intake is inadequate, calcium is removed from storage sites in bone
and used to keep blood levels constant. Other hormones which affect
calcium levels include estrogens, glucocorticoids, thyroid hormone,
insulin and growth hormones.
Absorption is enhanced when calcium intake is low1
and also by moderate exercise. Lactose, vitamin D and adequate (but not
excessive) protein improve calcium absorption. High levels of fat reduce
absorption. Compounds known as phytates, which are found in dietary
fiber; and oxalates, which are found in leafy greens, reduce absorption.
The acid environment of the stomach makes calcium salts more soluble,
and therefore easier to absorb; and low stomach acid reduces absorption.
Absorption and retention of calcium become less
efficient with age,2 partly due to lower estrogen and testosterone
levels; and a postmenopausal woman may only absorb 7 percent of her
dietary intake. The ability to absorb and retain calcium improves during
pregnancy although it seems that some calcium is drawn from bone stores
later in pregnancy. A study done in 1996 in Cincinnati showed that
breastfeeding stimulates increases in calcium absorption and these
increases become apparent after weaning or after menstrual periods
restart.3
Smoking, high refined sugar intake, caffeine, alcohol
and excess salt promote calcium excretion, thereby increasing the risk
of deficiency. High protein diets also increase calcium excretion,
particularly if the protein comes from meat.4
Deficiency
Mild calcium deficiency can cause nerve sensitivity, muscle
twitching, brittle nails, irritability, palpitations and insomnia. Signs
of severe deficiency include abnormal heartbeat, muscle pains and
cramps, numbness, stiffness and tingling of the hands and feet, and
depression. Children can suffer from rickets, a disease characterized by
excessive sweating of the head; slowness in sitting, crawling and
walking; insomnia; bone deformities; and growth retardation. In adults,
deficiency can lead to osteomalacia with symptoms of bone pain, muscle
weakness and delayed healing of fractures.
Those at risk of calcium deficiency include the
elderly, people who don’t eat dairy products or other high calcium
foods, athletes, those on high protein or high fiber diets, and those
who drink a lot of alcohol. High dietary levels of phosphorus cause
calcium to be removed from bone and excreted. Phosphorus is found in
many common foods such as meat, cheese, processed foods and soda drinks,
and people who consume large amount of these foods are at increased risk
of calcium deficiency. People on weight-reducing diets are also at risk
as they may avoid high calorie foods, which are often good sources of
calcium.
Studies have shown that calcium is deficient in the
diets of many women. The National Osteoporosis Foundation estimates that
the average adult in the US gets only 500 to 700 mg per day. Calcium
deficiency is relatively common in many countries.
Osteoporosis
Calcium deficiency contributes to osteoporosis, which literally
means "porous bones" and in some cases, can be so severe as to
cause the bones to break under the weight of the body. Particularly
badly affected bones include the spinal vertebrae, the thigh bone and
the radius (shorter arm bone). The symptoms of osteoporosis may be
absent until fractures occur, although in some cases there may be back
pain.
Osteoporosis is most common in elderly white women
with a history of borderline calcium intake. Around 35 percent of women
suffer from osteoporosis after menopause and, although it is less
common, the problem occurs in a similar way in men. Most of the bone
loss seen in osteoporosis occurs in the first five to six years after
menopause due to a decline in circulating estrogens and an age-related
reduction in vitamin D production.
Good nutrition plays a role in reducing the incidence
of osteoporosis by promoting the development of favorable peak bone mass
during the first 30 to 40 years of life. Getting enough calcium in early
adolescence and early adulthood is vital for bones to reach their
maximum density so that they are strong enough to support the body even
when they lose density later in life. Studies suggest that calcium
intake in adolescence is often below the recommended levels. Researchers
involved in a 1994 USDA study measured calcium intake in 51 girls aged 5
to16 years old. They found calcium intake to be below the recommended
dietary allowance for 21 out of 25 girls aged 11 or over. These studies
suggest that the current calcium intake of American girls during the
puberty is not enough to enable bones to develop maximum strength and
that increased intakes may be necessary.5
However, it is never too late to slow the bone-loss
seen in osteoporosis, and early postmenopausal years are also an
important time to ensure optimal intake. A 1997 study done at King’s
College Hospital in London suggests that high calcium intakes are linked
to bone mineral density in elderly women. Researchers assessed calcium
intake in 124 women aged from 52 to 62 and also measured bone mineral
density at the spine, hip and foot (os calcis). Results showed that
women with high calcium intakes had higher bone mineral density.6
Results from the Rotterdam Study, which involves 1
856 men and 2 452 women aged 55 years and over also show that high
calcium intakes also protect against bone loss in men.7
Calcium deficiency is only one factor in
osteoporosis. There is likely to be a genetic component and other
dietary, behavioral and hormonal factors also play a major part.
Adequate intakes of vitamin D, magnesium and boron are also necessary to
build healthy bones. Body weight is the factor most linked to bone
mineral density and, in women, body fat may be at least as important as
muscle in maintaining bone mineral content. Weight-bearing exercise,
adequate lifelong calcium intake, and moderate alcohol intake all play
important roles in preventing osteoporosis. Estrogen replacement therapy
is often used to treat osteoporosis.
Bone loss is found to be up to 11
percent greater
during the night. Calcium levels are also lowest during the night and
may be affected by the concentration of the hormone, cortisol. These
findings may lead to new hormone treatments for osteoporosis.
Cancer
Calcium deficiency may be linked to an increased risk of colon
cancer. Research on animals and some epidemiological studies suggest
that people with high calcium intakes are less likely to develop colon
cancer. Research findings in humans are inconclusive, with some studies
showing protective effects while others have not. The overall results
seem to suggest that the protective effect of high calcium intake does
exist but that it is not very marked.
The association between calcium intake and deaths
from gastrointestinal cancer was assessed in a 28-year follow-up study
of 2 591 Dutch civil servants and their spouses, aged 40 to 65 years.
The researchers found that men and women who died of colorectal cancer
had a lower average calcium intake compared to the rest of the
population.8
Results from the Iowa Women’s Health Study
published in 1998 showed that calcium can decrease the risk of rectal
cancer. Researchers analyzed information from 34 702 postmenopausal
women who responded to a mailed survey in 1986. After nine years of
follow-up, 144 rectal cancer cases were identified. The results showed
that high total calcium intake reduced the risk of rectal cancer.9
Other results from this study show a reduced risk of colon cancer in
women with high intakes of calcium and vitamin D.
In a 1996 study, Harvard University researchers
working on the Health Professionals Study assessed the links between
calcium intake and colon cancer in almost 48 000 men aged from 40 to 75.
They found that higher intake of calcium from foods and supplements was
associated with a lower cancer risk until they adjusted their results to
take other factors into account. They concluded that calcium may
possibly mildly lower the risk of colon cancer.10 Data from the Nurses
Health Study, which involved over 89 000 nurses, also showed a small
reduced risk.11
Calcium may exert its protective effects by binding
to toxic substances such as bile acids and fats and reduce the chance
that these will cause cancerous changes in the gut. Calcium may also
normalize the growth of cells in the intestinal wall, thus protecting
against cancerous changes. Limited evidence suggests that low calcium
intake may also increase the risk of breast, cervical and esophageal
cancers.
Taiwanese studies done in 1997 and 1998 showed a
protective effect both against gastric and colorectal cancers from high
levels of calcium in drinking water.12,13
Blood pressure
Calcium metabolism seems to be altered in people with hypertension.
Several studies suggest that low dietary intake of calcium is associated
with an increased risk of developing hypertension and cardiovascular
disease. Some research suggests studies show that restriction of calcium
increases, and supplementation with calcium lowers, blood pressure. Data
from the US Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES I) showed
that hypertensive people consumed 18 percent less dietary calcium than
those with normal blood pressure.14
A review published in 1997 in the American Journal
of Clinical Nutrition showed that experimental data support the view
that when adults meet or exceed the recommended dietary allowances of
calcium, potassium, and magnesium, high sodium intakes are not
associated with high blood pressure. Thus adequate mineral intake may
protect against salt sensitivity. (See page 232 for more information.)15
Some evidence suggests that a woman who eats a low
calcium diet in pregnancy may also increase the chances of her child
suffering from high blood pressure.
Muscle cramps
When blood calcium levels drop below normal, the sensitivity of the
nerves can increase, leading to muscle cramps. Pregnant women whose
diets are deficient in calcium are at greatest risk of muscle cramps.
Teeth
Severe calcium deficiency can lead to periodontal disease
(inflammation and degeneration of the bone and gum structures that
support the teeth).
Sources
Good sources of calcium include milk and other dairy products, kale,
kelp, tofu, canned fish with bones, peanuts, walnuts, sunflower seeds,
broccoli, cauliflower and soybeans. Fortified foods such as fruit
juices, breads and cereals are also common sources. Calcium in hard
water and some mineral waters may be important dietary sources for some
people.16
Calcium from milk and milk products is absorbed more
easily than that from most vegetables, with the exception of dark green
leafy vegetables such as kale, broccoli, turnip and mustard greens. A
1990 study showed that more calcium is absorbed from kale than from
milk.17
Green leafy vegetables such as spinach contain large
amounts of calcium but also contain oxalic acid which binds calcium and
prevents it from being absorbed. Insoluble fiber, such as that found in
wheat bran, reduces calcium absorption; but soluble fiber, such as that
found in psyllium and fruit pectins, does not seem to affect
absorption.18
While dairy products are good sources of calcium,
there is concern that their protein content can increase the loss of
calcium from bone. Results from the ongoing Nurses Health Study suggest
that drinking lots of milk and other dairy foods high in calcium does
not protect older women against bone fractures. Researchers analyzed the
diets of over 77 000 participants in the study and looked at the rates
of bone fractures. Results showed that women who drank two or more
glasses of milk per day had around a 45 percent increased risk of hip
fracture and a 5 percent increased risk of forearm fracture compared to
women who drank one glass or less per week. There was also no drop in
risk with intake of calcium from other dairy foods.19
In another study done in 1995 at the University of
California at Berkeley, researchers assessed the effect of calcium
supplementation and drinking milk on pre-eclampsia in over 9000 pregnant
women. Results showed that women who drank two glasses of milk per day
had the lowest risk. The risk for those drinking one glass of milk per
day was similarly low but the risk for those drinking less than one
glass of milk per day was substantially higher. Women drinking three or
more glasses of milk per day also showed increased risk as did those
drinking four or more glasses per day.20
A varied diet which includes nondairy sources of
calcium is likely to be more beneficial in protecting against
osteoporosis and other disorders of calcium deficiency.
Almonds, blanched
¼ cup 89 mg
|
Cauliflower
½ cup 10 mg
|
Fruit yogurt
1 tub 338 mg
|
Milk chocolate
1 bar 84 mg
|
Milk, whole
1 cup 291 mg
|
Soybeans
1 cup 55 mg
|
Baked beans, canned
1 cup 127 mg
|
Cheddar cheese
1 slice 204 mg
|
Honeydew melon
1 cup, diced 10 mg
|
Milk, dry, nonfat
¼ cup 377 mg
|
Peanuts
1/2 cup 134 mg
|
Tahini paste
1 tbsp 64 mg
|
Brazil nuts
½ cup 123 mg
|
Crab meat, canned
1 cup, drained 136 mg
|
Kale, cooked
1 cup 94 mg
|
Milk, evaporated
1 cup 658 mg
|
Salmon, canned
½ can 484 mg
|
Tofu
½ cup 204 mg
|
Broccoli, cooked
½ cup 36 mg
|
Figs, dried
5 figs 135 mg
|
Kelp, raw
2 tbsp 17 mg
|
Milk, nonfat
1 cup 297 mg
|
Sardines, canned, tomato sauce
5 sardines 455 mg
|
Walnuts
1 cup, shelled 94 mg
|
Recommended dietary allowances
Calcium requirements vary throughout a person’s lifetime, with
greater needs during periods of rapid growth and later in life. Due to
mounting evidence that people are not getting enough calcium to prevent
osteoporosis and other bone diseases, in 1997 the US government raised
the recommendations for how much calcium people should consume every
day.
Recommended intakes for pregnant and breastfeeding
women are no longer greater than those for other women. This is partly
based on recent studies which suggest that changes in calcium metabolism
and absorption during pregnancy and breastfeeding are enough to meet the
extra demands placed on a woman’s body by her baby. A 1998 British
study suggests that bone mineral density changes seen during
breastfeeding seems to be unrelated to dietary calcium intake.21
Two randomized, placebo-controlled trials of calcium
supplementation were done on new mothers in 1997 in Cincinnati, Ohio.
Researchers tested the effect of 1000 mg of calcium per day on bone
density, measured at enrolment and after three and six months. The
results showed no effect of either lactation or calcium supplementation
on bone density in the forearm, and also no effect of calcium
supplementation on the calcium concentration in breast milk.22
In another study published in 1998, researchers
studied calcium metabolism in 14 pregnant women from before conception
to five months after their periods restarted. When the women were
pregnant the increased needs were met by improved absorption, and then
during the early breastfeeding period calcium excretion decreased. Some
calcium was drawn from bone but this was recovered after menstruation
restarted, although not to pre-pregnancy levels.23
The women involved in this study were all consuming
adequate levels of calcium and it is possible that women whose calcium
intake is lower than 1300 mg per day may benefit from extra calcium or
supplements.
Men 1000 mg
(14-18) 1300 mg
(over 50) 1200 mg
|
Women 1000 mg
(14-18) 1300 mg
(over 50) 1200 mg
|
Pregnancy 1000 mg
(14-18) 1300 mg
|
Lactation 1000 mg
(14-18) 1300 mg
|
|
Men 800 mg
|
Women 800 mg
(post menopause) 1000 mg
|
Pregnancy 1100 mg
|
Lactation 1300 mg
|
The tolerable upper intake level for children over
the age of one and adults has been set at 2500 mg per day.
Supplements
Several dietary studies suggest that in many population groups,
calcium intake is inadequate, particularly in women. As few as 10
percent of elderly people are getting enough calcium to prevent bone loss
and are likely to benefit from supplements. Pregnant and breastfeeding
women, adolescent girls, postmenopausal women and vegans may also
benefit.
What type to take
Calcium supplements are among those most often prescribed by doctors
as calcium deficiency is relatively common. They contain different
amounts of calcium and are available in various forms including calcium
carbonate (which contains 40 percent calcium), calcium aspartate,
calcium citrate (21 percent calcium), calcium gluconate (9 percent
calcium) and calcium lactate (13 percent calcium). While multivitamins
do contain some calcium, the amount is not usually sufficient to meet
daily requirements and separate calcium supplements are more useful.
Bonemeal, dolomite and oyster shells are common
sources of calcium, but they should be avoided as they may be
contaminated with lead and cadmium, which can be toxic. Antacids are
also good sources of calcium, but those containing aluminum or sodium
should be avoided as aluminum inhibits calcium absorption and sodium can
raise blood pressure. Calcium citrate, which is an acidified form of
calcium supplement, is absorbed better than calcium carbonate.24 This is
particularly important in older people who have low stomach acid.
Calcium lactate and calcium aspartate are also well-absorbed. Calcium
carbonate may cause side effects such as nausea, gas and constipation;
but taking it in divided doses with meals may reduce these side effects
and improve absorption.25
When to take calcium supplements
Absorption of calcium from supplements is considerably reduced in
people who have low stomach acid unless the supplements are taken with
food. In general, it seems that calcium supplements are better absorbed
if they are taken with a meal, although this depends on the type of food
eaten at the meal, for example, less calcium will be absorbed if
supplements are taken with foods high in calcium, insoluble fiber and
oxalates. A 1989 study showed that a light meal improved calcium
absorption from milk, calcium carbonate and calcium-citrate-malate
sources.26 However, calcium may decrease the absorption of other
minerals such as zinc. Some calcium supplements can interfere with iron
absorption, although this does not seem to be the case with calcium
citrate and calcium ascorbate as they are acidic.
Some experts advise taking two-thirds of the daily
calcium dose at bedtime and the rest in the morning. Others recommend
dividing the dose into four parts; i.e. with meals and at bedtime.27 As
bone loses calcium at night, some experts recommend taking supplements
then to maintain blood calcium levels.
Calcium and magnesium
If you take a calcium supplement, you should also take a magnesium
supplement. This helps to avoid constipation and to balance the effect
of calcium on the electrical impulses in the nerves and muscles. Calcium
and magnesium work together as mild neuromuscular relaxants. Some
experts recommend taking calcium and magnesium in a 2:1 ratio while
others suggest 1:1.
Toxic effects of excess intake
Toxic effects are rare as the body can excrete excess calcium with
doses up to 2500 mg per day considered safe. Some people may suffer
constipation at these doses. Daily intakes above 2500 mg may cause
kidney stones and other problems. At very large doses, such as 25 000
mg, vomiting, nausea and loss of appetite can occur. If taken with high
levels of vitamin D for long periods, deposition of calcium in the
kidneys, heart and other soft tissues can occur. High levels may also
impair vitamin K metabolism, reduce iron and zinc absorption, and affect
the activity of neurons in the brain which control mood and emotion.
Calcium forms part of the plaque laid down in the
arteries in atherosclerosis, although this problem is likely to be due
to abnormalities in calcium metabolism rather than excess dietary
calcium.
Results from the Health Professionals Follow-Up study
which involved
47 781 men suggest that high calcium intakes from
both food and supplements increase the risk of prostate cancer.28
Therapeutic uses of supplements
Osteoporosis
Research suggests that taking calcium supplements later in life can
slow the bone loss associated with osteoporosis. Treatment which
combines calcium and estrogen is likely to be better at building bone
than treatment with estrogen alone, according to a review published in
1998 in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition.
Researchers analyzed the results of 31 studies and
found that the postmenopausal women who took estrogen alone had an
average increase in spinal bone mass of 1.3 percent per year, while
those who took estrogen and calcium supplements had an average increase
of 3.3 percent. Increases in bone mass in the forearm and upper thigh
were also greater in women taking supplements. The added benefit from
the calcium was seen when the women increased their intake from an
average of 563 mg per day to 1200 mg per day.29
Another study done in 1997 at Tufts University in
Boston showed reduced rates of bone loss and fractures in men and women
over 65 who took calcium and vitamin D supplements. Researchers assessed
the effects of calcium (500 mg per day) and vitamin D (700 IU per day)
on 176 men and 213 women aged 65 years or older. After a three-year
period, those taking the supplements had higher bone density at all body
sites measured. The fracture rate was also reduced by 50 percent in
those taking the supplements.30
Calcium supplements have also been shown to increase
bone mass in children, although a 1996 study done in Hong Kong found
that when the supplements were stopped, the beneficial effects
disappeared.31
Protection against the side effects of corticosteroid drugs
One of the side effects of corticosteroid drugs,
which are often used to treat arthritis, asthma and other chronic
diseases, is a loss of bone mineral density and therefore an increased
risk of osteoporosis.
In a study done in 1996 at the Medical College of
Virginia, researchers showed that calcium and vitamin D supplements can
help prevent this loss. In the two-year study, 96 patients with
rheumatoid arthritis, 65 of whom were taking corticosteroid drugs, were
given 1000 mg calcium and 500 IU vitamin D per day or placebo. The
researchers analyzed the bone mineral density of the lumbar spine and
femur for one year. In those patients taking corticosteroid drugs and
placebo losses of bone mineral density were seen. In those taking the
supplements, gains were seen and in those not taking corticosteroids,
the supplements did not appear to affect bone mineral density.32
Blood pressure
Some studies have shown that calcium supplements lower blood
pressure in mildly hypertensive patients, while others have shown no
effect.
In an eight-week randomized, placebo-controlled study
done in 1985 in the US, researchers assessed the effect of 1000 mg per
day of calcium supplements on the blood pressure of 48 people with
hypertension and 32 without. Compared with placebo, calcium
significantly lowered both systolic and diastolic blood pressures, but
only in those with high blood pressure.33
Results from the University of Pittsburgh Trials of
Hypertension Prevention (TOHP) showed calcium supplements (100 mg per
day) to have little effect on blood pressure. The participants were
healthy adult men and women (both white and African American) aged 30 to
54 years with high-normal diastolic blood pressure. However, the
supplements did seem to lower blood pressure in white women, who are at
particular risk of low calcium intakes.34 Supplements may be beneficial
in cases where calcium intake is insufficient, which may be relatively
common. Whether calcium can lower blood pressure in cases where there is
no apparent deficiency is not clear. Increasing calcium intake may lower
blood pressure by increasing the excretion of sodium and calcium
supplements may be most useful in those who are salt sensitive. (See
page 232 for more information.)
The results of a study, reported in 1997 in the British
Medical Journal, suggest that women who take calcium supplements in
pregnancy have children with lower blood pressures. Researchers measured
the blood pressures of almost 600 children of women who had previously
been involved in a double-blind trial of the effects of calcium on blood
pressure during pregnancy. The results showed that, overall, systolic
blood pressure was lower in the calcium group, particularly among
overweight children.35
Muscle cramps
Calcium can be used to control the incidence of leg cramps in
pregnant women, possibly by decreasing nerve irritability. It has also
been used to reduce the incidence of menstrual cramps and symptoms
associated with premenstrual syndrome.
Pre-eclampsia
Use of calcium supplements during pregnancy may lower a woman’s
risk of pre-eclampsia, a disorder which occurs in one in every 20
pregnant women. Symptoms of pre-eclampsia are high blood pressure,
headache, protein in the urine, blurred vision and anxiety. It can lead
to eclampsia, a seizure disorder which can cause complications with
pregnancy and even death. There is some evidence that abnormalities in
calcium metabolism are involved in pre-eclampsia. Many pregnant women do
not consume enough calcium to ensure optimal blood pressure regulation
and the results of several clinical trials have suggested that calcium
supplements reduce the incidence of pre-eclampsia.36
A 1996 analysis of clinical trials which looked at
the effects of calcium intake on pre-eclampsia and pregnancy outcomes in
2500 women found that those who consumed 1500 to 2000 mg of calcium
supplements per day were 70 percent less likely to suffer from high
blood pressure in pregnancy.37
However, in a study published in 1997 in the New
England Journal of Medicine, researchers found that calcium
supplements did not prevent pre-eclampsia. The study, the largest ever
done on the subject, involved 4589 healthy, first-time mothers. Half of
the subjects received 2000 mg of calcium per day and the other half
received a placebo. The researchers then assessed the incidence of high
blood pressure and protein excretion in the urine. No significant
differences in the groups were found. Supplements did not reduce other
complications associated with childbirth or increase the incidence of
kidney stones.38
The results of this study still leave open the
possibility that calcium supplements may be useful as the women included
in the study were already consuming higher than average levels of
calcium than is typical even before they took the supplements. Women at
high risk of pre-eclampsia were also not included in the investigation.
Other uses
Calcium supplements can be useful in congestive heart failure as
they increase the contractility of heart muscle. Calcium salts are used
intravenously to treat heart attack associated with high potassium and
magnesium levels and low calcium levels. They are also used in cases of
calcium antagonist drug overdose.
Calcium supplements have also been used to treat
allergy complaints, depression, panic attacks, arthritis, hypoglycemia,
muscle and joint pains. Calcium salts are a major component of antacids
which are used to treat indigestion and ulcers. Taken with magnesium,
they may have neuromuscular relaxing effects and may be useful in
insomnia.
Interactions with other nutrients
Calcium and phosphorus work together to form healthy bones and
teeth. High phosphorus intakes lead to increased calcium excretion. The
intake ratio for calcium to phosphorus should be 1:1.
Calcium competes with zinc, manganese, copper and
iron for absorption in the intestine, and a high intake of one mineral
can reduce absorption of the others. This is of particular concern in
the case of iron. Calcium reduces both heme and nonheme iron
absorption.39 (See page 251 for more information.) The practical
implications of the inhibitory effect of calcium mean that addition of
milk or cheese to common meals such as pizza or hamburgers can reduce
iron absorption by 50-60%. Some experts recommend eating foods that
provide most of the daily iron intake at a different time to foods which
provide most of the daily calcium intake. Thus it is advisable to reduce
the intake of dairy products with the main meals providing most of the
dietary iron, especially for children, teenagers and women of
childbearing age whose iron requirements are high.40
This interaction is also a concern in relation to
supplements as calcium and iron are both commonly recommended for women.
A study done in 1990 on postmenopausal women showed that calcium
supplements decrease iron absorption from supplements and from food
sources. Orange juice helped to avoid this reduction in absorption
probably because it contains citric and ascorbic acids, both of which
are known to enhance iron absorption.41 However, calcium citrate does
not appear to reduce iron absorption.42
Lead absorption is blocked by calcium in the
intestines. Boron supplementation may reduce the excretion of calcium.
Aluminum-containing antacids can inhibit calcium absorption. It is
unclear whether magnesium inhibits calcium absorption. A 1994 study
found no effect of magnesium supplements on calcium absorption.43
Calcium supplements have been shown to decrease zinc absorption.44 High
calcium diets are being increasingly recommended to prevent osteoporosis
and a 1997 study done in the US showed that high calcium diets decreased
zinc absorption by 50 percent and may raise requirements.45
Boron seems to be beneficial to calcium metabolism.
Calcium interacts with several vitamins, in particular, vitamin D and
vitamin K.
Interactions with drugs
Some diuretics, corticosteroids and antidepressants can lead to
calcium deficiency. Calcium supplements may decrease the effectiveness
of tetracycline antibiotics; the anticonvulsant, phenytoin; and aspirin;
and should not be taken at the same time as any of these drugs.
Cautions
Calcium supplements should not be used in people who have impaired
kidney function, cardiac arrhythmias, a history of kidney or bladder
stones, constipation or dehydration. The calcium citrate form of
supplement is less likely to cause kidney stones than calcium carbonate.
1 OBrien KO; Abrams SA; Liang LK;
Ellis KJ; Gagel RF Increased efficiency of calcium absorption during
short periods of inadequate calcium intake in girls. Am J Clin Nutr,
1996 Apr, 63:4, 579-83
2 Heaney RP; Recker RR; Stegman MR;
Moy AJ Calcium absorption in women: relationships to calcium intake,
estrogen status, and age. J Bone Miner Res, 1989 Aug, 4:4, 469-75
3 Kalkwarf HJ; Specker BL; Heubi JE;
Vieira NE; Yergey AL. Intestinal calcium absorption of women during
lactation and after weaning. Am J Clin Nutr, 1996 Apr, 63:4, 526-31
4 Itoh R; Nishiyama N; Suyama Y.
Dietary protein intake and urinary excretion of calcium: a
cross-sectional study in a healthy Japanese population. Am J Clin Nutr
1998;67:438-44
5 Abrams SA; Stuff JE Calcium
metabolism in girls: current dietary intakes lead to low rates of
calcium absorption and retention during puberty. Am J Clin Nutr, 1994
Nov, 60:5, 739-43
6 Suleiman S, Nelson M, Li F,
Buxton-Thomas M, Moniz C. Effect of calcium intake and physical activity
level on bone mass and turnover in healthy, white, postmenopausal women.
Am J Clin Nutr 1997 Oct;66(4):937-943
7 Burger H et al Risk Factors for
Increased Bone Loss in an Elderly Population The Rotterdam Study. Am J
Epidemiol 1998;147:871-9
8 Slob IC; Lambregts JL; Schuit AJ;
Kok FJ. Calcium intake and 28-year gastro-intestinal cancer mortality in
Dutch civil servants. Int J Cancer, 1993 Apr 22, 54:1, 20-5
9 Zheng W; Anderson KE; Kushi LH;
Sellers TA; Greenstein J; Hong CP; Cerhan JR; Bostick RM; Folsom AR. A
prospective cohort study of intake of calcium, vitamin D, and other
micronutrients in relation to incidence of rectal cancer among
postmenopausal women. Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev, 1998 Mar, 7:3,
221-5
10 Kearney J; Giovannucci E; Rimm EB;
Ascherio A; Stampfer MJ; Colditz GA; Wing A; Kampman E; Willett WC.
Calcium, vitamin D, and dairy foods and the occurrence of colon cancer
in men. Am J Epidemiol, 1996 May, 143:9, 907-17
11 Martínez ME; Giovannucci EL;
Colditz GA; Stampfer MJ; Hunter DJ; Speizer FE; Wing A; Willett WC.
Calcium, vitamin D, and the occurrence of colorectal cancer among women.
J Natl Cancer Inst, 1996 Oct, 88:19, 1375-82
12 Yang CY; Chiu HF; Chiu JF; Tsai SS;
Cheng MF. Calcium and magnesium in drinking water and risk of death from
colon cancer. Jpn J Cancer Res, 1997 Oct, 88:10, 928-33
13 Yang CY; Cheng MF; Tsai SS; Hsieh
YL Calcium, magnesium, and nitrate in drinking water and gastric cancer
mortality. Jpn J Cancer Res, 1998 Feb, 89:2, 124-30
14 McCarron DA Calcium and magnesium
nutrition in human hypertension. Ann Intern Med, 1983 May, 98:5 Pt 2,
800-5
15 McCarron DA Role of adequate
dietary calcium intake in the prevention and management of
salt-sensitive hypertension. Am J Clin Nutr, 1997 Feb, 65:2 Suppl,
712S-716S
16 Wynckel A; Hanrotel C; Wuillai A;
Chanard J Intestinal calcium absorption from mineral water. Miner
Electrolyte Metab, 1997, 23:2, 88-92
17 Heaney RP; Weaver CM Calcium
absorption from kale. Am J Clin Nutr, 1990 Apr, 51:4, 656-7
18 Heaney RP; Smith KT; Recker RR;
Hinders SM. Meal effects on calcium absorption. Am J Clin Nutr, 1989
Feb, 49:2, 372-6
19 Feskanich D; Willett WC; Stampfer
MJ; Colditz GA Milk, dietary calcium, and bone fractures in women: a
12-year prospective study. Am J Public Health, 1997 Jun, 87:6, 992-7
20 Richardson BE; Baird DD. A study of
milk and calcium supplement intake and subsequent preeclampsia in a
cohort of pregnant women. Am J Epidemiol, 1995 Apr, 141:7, 667-73
21 Laskey MA; Prentice A; Hanratty LA;
Jarjou LMA; Dibba B; Beavan SR; Cole TJ. Bone changes after 3 mo of
lactation: influence of calcium intake, breast-milk output, and vitamin
D—receptor genotype. Am J Clin Nutr 1998;67:685-92.
22 Kalkwarf HJ, Specker BL, Bianchi
DC, Ranz J, Ho M. The effect of calcium supplementation on bone density
during lactation and after weaning. N Engl J Med 1997;337:523-8
23 Ritchie LD; Fung EB; Halloran BP;
Turnlund JR; Van Loan MD; Cann CE; King JC. A longitudinal study of
calcium homeostasis during human pregnancy and lactation and after
resumption of menses. Am J Clin Nutr 1998;67:693-701.
24 Harvey JA; Kenny P; Poindexter J;
Pak CY Superior calcium absorption from calcium citrate than calcium
carbonate using external forearm counting. J Am Coll Nutr, 1990 Dec,
9:6, 583-7
25 Blanchard J; Aeschlimann JM.
Calcium absorption in man: some dosing recommendations. J Pharmacokinet
Biopharm, 1989 Dec, 17:6, 631-44
26 Heaney RP, Weaver CM. Effect of
psyllium on absorption of co-ingested calcium. J Am Geriatr Soc 1995
Mar;43(3):261-263
27 Heaney RP. Calcium supplements:
practical considerations. Osteoporos Int 1991 Feb;1(2):65-71
28 Giovannucci E; Rimm EB; Wolk A;
Ascherio A; Stampfer MJ; Colditz GA; Willett WC. Calcium and fructose
intake in relation to risk of prostate cancer. Cancer Res, 1998 Feb,
58:3, 442-7
29 Nieves JW, Komar L, Cosman F,
Lindsay R. Calcium potentiates the effect of estrogen and calcitonin on
bone mass: review and analysis. Am J Clin Nutr 1998;67:5-6, 18-24
30 Dawson-Hughes B, Harris SS, Krall
EA, Dallal GE. Effect of calcium and vitamin D supplementation on bone
density in men and women 65 years of age or older. N Engl J Med 1997 Sep
4;337(10):670-676
31 Lee WT, Leung SS, Leung DM, Cheng
JC. A follow-up study on the effects of calcium-supplement withdrawal
and puberty on bone acquisition of children. Am J Clin Nutr 1996
Jul;64(1):71-77
32 Buckley LM; Leib ES; Cartularo KS;
Vacek PM; Cooper SM. Calcium and vitamin D3 supplementation prevents
bone loss in the spine secondary to low-dose corticosteroids in patients
with rheumatoid arthritis. A randomized, double-blind,
placebo-controlled trial. Ann Intern Med, 1996 Dec, 125:12, 961-8
33 McCarron DA; Morris CD Blood
pressure response to oral calcium in persons with mild to moderate
hypertension. A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, crossover
trial. Ann Intern Med, 1985 Dec, 103:6 ( Pt 1), 825-31
34 Yamamoto ME; Applegate WB; Klag MJ;
Borhani NO; Cohen JD; Kirchner KA; Lakatos E; Sacks FM; Taylor JO;
Hennekens CH Lack of blood pressure effect with calcium and magnesium
supplementation in adults with high-normal blood pressure. Results from
Phase I of the Trials of Hypertension Prevention (TOHP). Trials of
Hypertension Prevention (TOHP) Collaborative Research Group. Ann
Epidemiol, 1995 Mar, 5:2, 96-107
35 Belizán JM; Villar J; Bergel E;
del Pino A; Di Fulvio S; Galliano SV; Kattan C. Long-term effect of
calcium supplementation during pregnancy on the blood pressure of
offspring: follow up of a randomised controlled trial. BMJ, 1997 Aug,
315:7103, 281-5
36 Herrera JA; Arevalo Herrera M;
Herrera S. Prevention of preeclampsia by linoleic acid and calcium
supplementation: a randomized controlled trial. Obstet Gynecol, 1998
Apr, 91:4, 585-90
37 Bucher HC; Guyatt GH; Cook RJ;
Hatala R; Cook DJ; Lang JD; Hunt D. Effect of calcium supplementation on
pregnancy-induced hypertension and preeclampsia: a meta-analysis of
randomized controlled trials. JAMA, 1996 Apr, 275:14, 1113-7
38 Levine RJ; Hauth JC; Curet LB;
Sibai BM; Catalano PM; Morris CD; DerSimonian R; Esterlitz JR; Raymond
EG; Bild DE; Clemens JD; Cutler JA. Trial of calcium to prevent
preeclampsia. N Engl J Med, 1997 Jul, 337:2, 69-76
39 Hallberg L; Brune M; Erlandsson M;
Sandberg AS; Rossander-Hultén L. Calcium: effect of different amounts
on nonheme- and heme-iron absorption in humans. Am J Clin Nutr, 1991
Jan, 53:1, 112-9
40 Pak CY; Stewart A; Haynes SD Effect
of added citrate or malate on calcium absorption from calcium-fortified
orange juice. J Am Coll Nutr, 1994 Dec, 13:6, 575-7
41 Hallberg L; Rossander-Hultén L;
Brune M; Gleerup A Calcium and iron absorption: mechanism of action and
nutritional importance. Eur J Clin Nutr, 1992 May, 46:5, 317-27
42 Deehr MS; Dallal GE; Smith KT;
Taulbee JD; Dawson-Hughes B. Effects of different calcium sources on
iron absorption in postmenopausal women. Am J Clin Nutr, 1990 Jan, 51:1,
95-9
43 Spencer H; Fuller H; Norris C;
Williams D. Effect of magnesium on the intestinal absorption of calcium
in man. J Am Coll Nutr, 1994 Oct, 13:5, 485-92
44 Argiratos V; Samman S. The effect
of calcium carbonate and calcium citrate on the absorption of zinc in
healthy female subjects. Eur J Clin Nutr, 1994 Mar, 48:3, 198-204
45 Wood RJ; Zheng JJ High dietary
calcium intakes reduce zinc absorption and balance in humans. Am J Clin
Nutr, 1997 Jun, 65:6, 1803-9

|